coologee.Contact
Case Studies
Financial Services

a regional property and casualty carrier

Brand advertising proven as a measurable driver of acquisition

The situation

What they were facing.

A large regional property and casualty carrier in the Northeast had invested heavily in performance marketing, and had no framework for understanding whether brand awareness and reputation were doing anything for lower-funnel results.

The organization could measure quote activity, web traffic and campaign performance. It could not answer whether brand advertising generated incremental business, how long the effect lasted, or whether sustained investment improved acquisition over time.

The Director of Brand needed to move the conversation from brand as a cost center to brand as a measurable business asset. That took a testing method rigorous enough to isolate the impact of brand media and quantify it.

What we did

The work.

Coologee worked as an extension of the internal team, alongside the Director of Brand, to design and run a market-based brand experiment answering one question: does sustained brand advertising create growth beyond what performance marketing alone delivers?

  • Brand experiment strategy
  • Test and control market selection
  • Measurement and attribution framework
  • Learning objectives and success criteria
  • Reporting across upper-, mid- and lower-funnel KPIs
  • Strategic counsel to the media agency throughout

The program ran in multiple waves, evaluating traffic, quote-start activity, direct and agent-driven acquisition, awareness, consideration, favorability and branded search. Continuous and pulsed media were both tested.

What changed

The outcome.

The experiment produced clear evidence that brand marketing delivered measurable business impact.

  • Test market traffic rose more than 414% year over year; the control market grew 5.7%.
  • During campaign periods, test market traffic rose nearly 430% while the control market declined.
  • Auto quote activity lifted measurably, particularly through direct digital channels.
  • Gains persisted after the campaign ended, indicating a halo effect.
  • Awareness, consideration, favorability and branded search all improved directionally.

The more durable outcome is the framework. The client has a repeatable way to evaluate the business value of brand investment, and a link between upper-funnel spend and acquisition that survives a budget conversation.

Facing something like this?

Tell us what you are working on. No qualification gauntlet — we qualify in the conversation, not on the page.